Is It Better To Have An Attached Or Detached Garage

Is It Better To Have An Attached Or Detached Garage?

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    A garage is an essential amenity for the vast majority of homes. As a place to park and store vehicles as well as other items like gardening tools, sports gear, bicycles, and more, a garage may be an indispensable part of a home. For many households, a garage is one of the most essential features of a house. In addition to storing your car there when you're not using it, you can also use it to hide other items from prying eyes.

    Some homebuyers prioritise a garage that is adjacent to the house, while others place a higher value on having a garage that is separate from the house. In what ways might one of these alternatives be better? Yet garages are not always the best option. What may function well in one home or for one family may not in another. You can choose whether or not to have a garage built into a new home throughout the house-hunting process.

    You can choose between a garage that is attached to the house or one that is isolated from the house. If you're reading this, you might be building a new house, remodelling the one you already have, or searching for a place to buy and move to. Regardless of your situation, you will always have to make a lot of choices. The advantages and disadvantages of each option are listed in detail. When weighing these two options, no one stands out as superior.

    There are advantages and merits to both choices. It's more important to identify your priorities and the most crucial components of the scenario than it is to choose the best possible course of action. We've produced a list of the benefits and drawbacks of both attached and detached garages to help you decide. This list isn't meant to convince you that any particular product is better than the rest; rather, it's meant to highlight the unique features of each option so you can pick the one that will serve you and your family best. So, let's weigh the pros and cons of both attached and detached garages.

    The Pros And Cons Of Freestanding Vs. Attached Garages

    An attached garage is a garage that is physically joined to a home by means of a wall connecting it to the house and from which direct access can be gained to the interior of the house. A detached garage is a garage that is not attached to the main house in any way, whether it is just a few feet or a few yards away.

    Garages That Are An Integral Part Of The Home

    Is It Better To Have An Attached Or Detached Garage2

    Carports with the "attached" prefix are those that are permanently fastened to the structure they protect, in this case a house. Garages attached to homes are like an extra room, with their own doors leading inside. They provide a place to park cars and a place to keep household goods out of the elements. The most prevalent type of garage on residential homes, the attached garage, often follows standard dimensions and shapes.

    Parking Spaces That Are Separate From The House

    Detached garages, on the other hand, are not attached to the house they serve. Therefore, garages may be found nearby, or they could be found on the opposite side of the property. Garages that are separated from their homes allow for more freedom in terms of layout and design.

    The Fundamentals Of Free-Standing Garages

    There are a lot of variables that could have an effect on the type of garage you end up with if you are in the process of building a new one on your property. You may be limited to creating an attached garage if the plot of land you have available is rather tiny. The space requirements of a detached garage mean that you probably won't be able to have one built unless your lot is quite sizable. The most common setup involves a dedicated garage lot. Until the advent of the attached garage, most garages were freestanding structures like carriage houses that were attached to their respective homes only by necessity.

    As replacements for similarly designed buildings, they share many of their features with the originals. For instance, they could sit on the other side of the driveway from the house, or at the very top of the driveway. They are self-contained apartments with every convenience provided. An automated overhead door, parking for two cars, and extra storage space are all standard features.

    There is no universal rule about whether or not garages have climate control systems; each location is different. Even while detached garages are more common, that doesn't mean they lack the modern sophistication of attached garages. These days, detached garages are standard on both newly built and older homes. Depending on the details of your scenario, a detached garage may provide the optimal balance of features and benefits to fulfil all of your needs.

    The Perks Of Having A Separate Garage

    To make the most of the space on a long, thin lot, a detached garage may be the best option. This style of garage can be positioned behind the home. With one of these garages, dangerous carbon monoxide emissions won't be able to seep into your house through the door. In addition, establishing a detached garage that has living quarters upstairs can be finished more quickly and at a lesser cost than attempting to develop a living space that is attached to the main house.

    It Fits An Older-Style Home Better. 

    Since attached garages are only a new architectural development, they can look out of place when added to older homes. You can still have an attached garage even if your home is rather old, but a detached garage will likely blend in better with the rest of your property. Attaching a detached garage to an older house might make it seem like a carriage house, and it will likely look much more at home and in keeping with the house's design. The earlier the house was constructed, the more likely this is to be the case.

    It's Further Away From Polluting Gases.

    Since garages are a handy location for storing chemicals, many people keep paint, powerful cleansers, weed and pest killers, and other similar products there. All of these can be safely handled and kept if done so in the right way, but there is always the risk that they have been incorrectly stored and are now releasing harmful gases. When your garage is connected to your home, the exhaust fumes might easily enter your home through simply one wall. Many homeowners find it reassuring to know that their cars, boats, and other recreational vehicles are stored in a building that is physically distinct from their principal property, such as a detached garage.

    There Are Fewer Wireless Access Points In The Home.

    A detached garage can make a homeowner feel safer since it eliminates an easy entrance point into their house. Many homeowners would consider this a significant perk. An intruder could access the home through a garage window if the garage is attached to the dwelling. The only thing blocking their way inside the house at that moment is the door that connects the garage to the house. A house break-in is a quick and easy task if this is left open. Building a detached garage solves this problem.

    The only ways in are the regular windows and doors. Even if the garage door is left unlocked, the level of security is not compromised. Consequently, from the standpoint of the homeowner, having a detached garage can provide a greatly increased sense of protection and safety in respect to any prospective invaders.

    The Added Privacy Is Appreciated.

    Some folks only store their car and a few tools in their garage. However, many people nowadays utilise their garages as workshops where they may work on home improvement projects, learn new skills, or even just store their cars while they work on them.

    However, garages are also frequently used as social gathering spots. Some people watch TV in their garages, while others make their garages into elaborate "man caves," and yet others let their kids practise loud instruments in the space. Someone who spends a lot of time in their garage may prefer a detached garage to a connected one for the added sense of privacy it offers.

    If your garage is attached, your family members can quickly and easily come and join you in any room of the house by just opening the door. However, if you don't want visitors, a detached garage may discourage them because of the small distance they have to go to get to your property.

    Reduces Indoor Noise Levels.

    The solitude of a detached garage may be more appealing if you utilise it as a place to relax away from the house. This thought follows from the one mentioned in the prior sentence. If you park across the driveway or somewhere comparably out of the way, you can shut out the house and all its noises and diversions. Naturally, this also holds true when using the inverse perspective.

    Let's say you spend a lot of time in the garage doing loud things like playing an instrument or working on a car. If that's the case, having a garage that's detached from the main house could help reduce noise levels in the rest of the home. It eliminates the garage's dominance over the front of the house. Most homes with attached garages devote the majority of the front yard to the garage door.

    Depending on the size of the home, it may consume almost as much room as the main entrance. This massive garage storage area will stand out even more if the rest of your home is on the compact side. An oversize garage linked to a modest home can make the latter appear to be being slowly consumed by the garage. The ultimate decision is, of course, one of taste. So, maybe the brightness doesn't bother you.

    On the other hand, a detached garage is a better option if you'd prefer have visitors notice your house than your garage. In other words, it allows for more expansion and improvement. Maybe you're set with the garage you have or the one you're going to construct. Who knows if you won't reassess your needs and decide that more room is necessary in the future? Then again, how do you know you won't change your mind and decide to build a home on top of the garage at some point?

    You May Easily Add On To A Detached Garage.

    When your garage is attached to your house, the amount of usable space you have is constrained, depending mostly on the amount of space already existent in the house. The garage's separation from the home allows for greater freedom in design, construction, and renovation.

    It Frees Up Additional Space For Gardening.

    If you put the garage on the other side of the driveway from the house, you'll be able to better utilise the area around your home. Given that your garage is detached from the house, you also have more room to experiment with creative gardening ideas. Some ideas for landscaping enhancements include more flower beds, a cobblestone path, or even a pond full of goldfish. It's also possible to create a patio area or a kitchen garden.

    Cons Of Freestanding Garages

    No vehicle will be able to get you there. Walking to and from a detached garage is not difficult during the warm summer months. There's a chance it'll even be a nice stroll. If you happen to reside in a region with a mild climate, this shouldn't be a problem either.

    However, if you happen to reside in a region where winters are particularly harsh, you'll have to battle the weather and go from your garage to your main residence. In other words, you'll be directly in the path of any snow, rain and wind that might come your way. On the other hand, if your garage is connected to your home, you may park your car inside, where it is safe from the elements, and then walk straight inside your home.

    Less People Can Easily Get To It.

    While the added privacy offered by a detached garage may be considered as a benefit, the garage's location away from the main house may be seen as a drawback. Attached garages make it easy to run inside for forgotten items or bathroom breaks. With a detached garage, the ease of merely strolling back and forth between your house and car is slightly lessened. When you've worked hard all day and are ready to kick back and relax, only to realise you forgot an essential tool and must return home to retrieve it, the experience can be incredibly irritating.

    It Is An Eyesore In The Yard.

    There aren't necessarily large expanses of unused land in the backyards of all houses. Adding a detached garage to your property can eat up a large section of your yard if space is already at a premium. This could be useful if you're hoping to cut down on the size of your yard that needs mowing and other upkeep. To be sure, this might be annoying if you're on the lookout for a sizable yard in which to let the kids and the pets run around and play.

    Construction Of This Is More Of An Undertaking.

    A garage can be built either separately or joined to your house if you're planning a renovation or new building. It's possible to do either, however building a detached garage will certainly take more time and energy. This is because you'll have at least one wall, and possibly two, to work with if your garage is attached to your house. To cut down on the amount of effort even further, you may turn a room in the house into a garage.

    It's possible that a detached garage could be integrated into an existing building in certain exceptional cases. If you are refurbishing a carriage house or an old shed, this particular issue may not be relevant to your job. However, when constructing a detached garage, you must normally start from scratch. That means you'll have to hire more people to help build your garage.

    It Will Cost More To Pay For Utilities.

    There will be more work involved if new utilities need to be installed when a detached garage is built or renovated. Extension of electrical wiring into the garage of a home with an attached garage is a simple and uncomplicated process because the wiring has already been run into the house.

    Extending the power to the end of the driveway or to the other side of the driveway if the garage is detached will require further work. The same holds true for the thermostat and the AC. If you plan on doing any kind of job in that location throughout the winter, you'll need some way to keep warm. Inevitably, this will cause more hassle and expense during the installation process.

    Guidelines For Constructing An Attached Garage

    Attached garages are a modern addition to residential design, with broad uptake not occurring until the 1950s. Many modern homes, however, still feature the more conventional detached garage rather than an attached one. Most homes constructed before the aforementioned era are affected by this.

    Having an attached garage has become increasingly common in recent years due to the many benefits it provides. Even though their sizes vary, most garages can fit at least one car. Most homes with garages have doors that lead straight into the home's main living areas, typically the kitchen, foyer, or mudroom. Whether or not an attached garage is ideal for you depends heavily on your needs and the nature of the neighbourhood and region in which you now dwell.

    The Benefits Of An Attached Garage

    Affixed garages are often less expensive than detached ones when it comes to house improvements. The building expenses for these are often lower than those for a brand new structure because you are using an existing wall and adding onto an existing structure. In addition, an attached building is preferable because it offers shelter from the elements on the way to and from your car. If you have a modest-sized home, one of these structures might be a lifesaver for stowing away often used goods. The space they offer is also perfect for a freezer or a second refrigerator.

    If you're thinking of renovating your current garage or constructing a new one, it's important to first gain an understanding of the key differences between detached and attached garages. In order to make an informed decision, you must be familiar with the advantages offered by each building type. After that, you can select the right one for you by thinking about your personal situation and health.

    If there's a storm outside, there's no need to go out in it. However, nothing beats the convenience of an attached garage, especially in less-than-ideal weather conditions as when it's raining, snowing, or windy outside.

    After parking, you enter the building while double-checking that the door is locked behind you. So far, you haven't had to brave the elements or go outside without your will. This is especially true for places that have harsh winters but also applies to places that have extremely hot summers. If you park in a garage that is connected to your house, you can avoid the oppressive heat entirely by going directly from your car's air cooling to your home's air conditioning.

    To Get To Is Very Simple.

    Access to an attached garage is far more convenient than that of a detached garage. It is much easier, more efficient, and more convenient to go back and forth between the home and the garage when only a door separates the two rather than a driveway's worth of space. This convenience is useful for a wide variety of reasons. It's convenient to have quick and easy access to the garage from the kitchen, where you might keep a second refrigerator.

    If you're doing business there, you probably won't want to take a business call while you're in the restroom. Perhaps your kids spend a lot of time in the garage and you need to ask them a question but you need to attract their attention quickly. All of these situations are made much easier by the garage's proximity to the house. It may give the impression that your home is more noticeable. Having an attached garage is a great option for homeowners who want to make their homes appear larger than they actually are.

    Depending on the dimensions of the garage and the home, an attached garage can create the impression that the home is twice as large as it actually is. In a tiny house, this won't improve the amount of usable space unless extra rooms are put above the garage, but it will make the property look much larger and more impressive from the street or the driveway.

    To Put It Another Way, It Helps You Make Better Use Of Your Yard.

    We talked about how a detached garage takes up a lot of room in the yard, making it less usable. It's the inverse in this case. Having a large amount of extra yard space is only one of the many benefits of having an attached garage.

    This could be a negative if you hate tending to your lawn, but a great perk if you have kids or pets who love to run around outside. This also allows you to add a garden and more trees, as well as a deck and a swimming pool. It's simpler to put together. An attached garage is nearly often a less complicated and cheaper addition to a new build than a detached one. The reason for this is that you probably already have one wall, and maybe even two, which will make up half of the garage's basic framework. That's around half the job done, so far.

    A detached garage, on the other hand, nearly always necessitates whole new construction from the ground up. The extra work and resources required are inevitable outcomes of this. Utilities will be made easier to use in a number of ways. If you have an attached garage, for example, and you want to put in HVAC, you won't have to go through a lot of hassle. Since these are usually already set up inside the home, transferring them to the garage is a breeze. Current electrical current is the same way. It will be considerably cheaper and easier to access than if utilities had to be run to an attached garage.

    Disadvantages Of Homes With Attached Garages

    Privacy Is Compromised.

    This restriction may or may not be a problem for you, depending on your plans for the garage. This probably won't be an issue if all you wish to do with it is park your car and keep a few extra boxes of stuff in it. However, if you use your garage as an office or just a location to get away from the home, this could be a drawback. Not only will you be able to hear the commotion and interruptions from home, but your loved ones will also find it simpler to drop by to see how things are progressing. If you're using power tools or doing something else that could be considered noisy, they'll be able to hear you, too. As a result, you'll be closer to pollutant emissions.

    Most chemicals, such as paints, insecticides, and other substances, can be used safely if proper safety procedures are implemented, but accidents sometimes happen and chemicals can release harmful vapours. However, if this does happen, you'll be less protected in an attached garage because there will be fewer walls between you and any possibly dangerous airborne pollutants. Obviously, this is a negative aspect. However, there is a safety benefit to having a garage that is not attached to the house.

    A Higher Level Of Danger To Security Is Presented.

    Although it might not seem so at first glance, attached garages are not quite as secure as detached ones. The garage door is often left unlocked, making it much easier for a thief to gain access to a home if they break in through a window. However, even if a thief gains access to a detached garage, they are still not in any danger of entering the residence.

    In An Older Home, It Could Look Out Of Place.

    Is It Better To Have An Attached Or Detached Garage3

    Adding a garage to an older house can be tricky because many of them were not built with garages in mind. Attached garage additions are possible, but they will likely look out of place and strange next to the rest of the house.

    Close Neighbourhoods Make Building Difficult.

    You may not have room for an attached garage if your neighbourhood's homes are built very closely together. Example: the shape of a typical small city lot is typically long and narrow. With this layout, a detached garage can be built at the end of the driveway behind the home, but there is limited area for a side extension of the house to accommodate a garage.


    Most homes need a garage. Some homebuyers value a detached garage over one attached to the house. We compared attached and detached garages' pros and cons. Attached garages are permanently attached to a house. With their own entrances, attached garages are like extra rooms.

    Detached garages are not connected to the house. Detached garages may meet all your demands. New and antique homes have attached garages. A detached garage prevents carbon monoxide from entering your home. Detached garages block homeowners' entrances. Social gatherings, workshops, and man-cabins are common in garages. Intruders must go far to reach a detached garage. It lowers indoor noise and increases privacy. If you'd rather visitors see your house, a separate garage is best. Design, building, and renovation are easier with the garage separate from the house.

    It makes room for a patio or kitchen garden. A separate garage makes it harder to walk between house and car. Attached garages make running inside for forgotten goods or potty breaks easy. If space is limited, they can take up a lot of yard. Depends on your needs. Most garages fit one car. If the garage is separate, powering the driveway requires more work. AC and thermostat work similarly. Affixed garages are cheaper to renovate than detached ones. An adjacent building protects you on your way to and from your car.

    They fit a freezer or second fridge. Homeowners who wish to make their homes look bigger can attach a garage. Without adding rooms over the garage, this won't increase usable space in a little house. It will make the property appear larger and more stunning from the street. A detached garage usually requires ground-up construction. HVAC and electricity will be simplified. Using it as an office or getaway compromises privacy. Unattached garages are safer. You'll be nearer to pollution emissions. Attached garages are riskier than detached ones.

    Content Summary

    1. Most homes need a garage.
    2. Garages are crucial for many families.
    3. Some purchasers prefer a detached garage, while others prefer an attached one.
    4. During house-hunting, you might choose to build a garage.
    5. Choose a detached or attached garage.
    6. Detailing each option's pros and cons.
    7. Both have benefits.
    8. We've included pros and cons of attached and detached garages to help you decide.
    9. A wall connects an attached garage to a residence, allowing direct access to the house's interior.
    10. Detached garages, whether a few feet or yards out, are not connected to the main house.
    11. Attached garages are the most common type of residential garage.
    12. Separated garages provide homeowners more design choices.
    13. If you're building a new garage, many factors can affect its design.
    14. If your lot is small, you may be limited to an attached garage.
    15. Garage climate control systems vary by location.
    16. New and older homes have detached garages today.
    17. Detached garages may offer the best combination of features and benefits for your situation.
    18. Detached garages maximise space on long, thin lots.
    19. This garage can be behind the house.
    20. Attached garages are new architectural features that may clash with older residences.
    21. Even if your home is ancient, a detached garage may look better.
    22. A detached garage attached to an older house may look like a carriage house and fit in better.
    23. Many homeowners feel safer storing their cars, yachts, and other recreational vehicles in a detached garage.
    24. A detached garage removes an accessible entry point, making a homeowner feel safer. If the garage is attached, an assailant could enter through a window.
    25. If left open, this makes housebreaking easier. Detached garages fix this. Only doors and windows allow entry.
    26. Security is unaffected by an unlocked garage door. Privacy is welcome.
    27. Detached garages provide more privacy for people who spend a lot of time in them.
    28. If your garage is attached, your family can immediately join you in any room simply opening the door.
    29. Use a separate garage as a place to rest to enjoy its tranquilly.
    30. If so, a detached garage may reduce household noise.
    31. It removes the garage's dominance.
    32. Most attached garages take up most of the front yard.
    33. It may take up as much space as the main entryway.
    34. If you want visitors to see your house, a separate garage is better.
    35. It allows growth and advancement.
    36. When your garage is attached to your house, your useful space is limited by the house's space.
    37. Design, building, and renovation are easier with the garage separate from the house. It creates planting space.
    38. Put the garage on the other side of the driveway from the house to maximise your home's space.
    39. Your detached garage gives you additional space to try out inventive gardening ideas.
    40. Summertime makes walking to and from a detached garage easy.
    41. If you live in a harsh winter climate, you'll have to brave the elements to get from your garage to your home.
    42. If your garage is attached to your home, you can park your car inside and walk right in.
    43. Detached garages offer more solitude, but their distance from the house may be a downside.
    44. Attached garages make running inside for forgotten goods or potty breaks easy. Yard eyesores.
    45. If space is limited, a detached garage might take up a lot of yard. If your garage is attached to your house, you'll have one or two walls to deal with.
    46. Detached garages must be built from scratch. You'll need extra workers to create your garage.
    47. Utilities will increase. Installing new utilities for a detached garage requires extra labour.
    48. Because the wire is already in the house, extending electrical wiring into an attached garage is easy.
    49. Your demands and your neighbourhood and location will determine whether an attached garage is right for you.
    50. Affixed garages are cheaper to renovate than detached ones. An adjacent building also provides shelter on your way to and from your automobile.
    51. Understand the distinctions between detached and attached garages before repairing or building one.
    52. Knowing each construction type's benefits helps you choose. After that, consider your health and personal condition to choose one.
    53. If you park in a garage linked to your house, you can bypass the terrible heat by going directly from your car's air conditioning to your home's.
    54. Attached garages are easier to access.
    55. If your kids spend a lot of time in the garage, you may need to quickly grab their attention to ask a question.
    56. The garage's proximity to the house simplifies these scenarios. It may make your home stand out.
    57. Homeowners who wish to make their homes look bigger can attach a garage.
    58. An attached garage can make a property appear twice as large, depending on its size.
    59. It improves yard use. Detached garages take up a lot of yard space, making it less usable.
    60. Attached garages provide greater yard space. Easy assembly.
    61. Attached garages are usually easier and cheaper to add to new builds.
    62. Since you likely have one or two walls, half of the garage's framework is already there.
    63. Several techniques will simplify utilities. Installing HVAC in an attached garage is easy.
    64. Transferring these to the garage is easy because they're already set up inside.
    65. It will be much cheaper and easier than running utilities to a connected garage.
    66. This restriction may or may not affect your garage designs.
    67. This may be a problem if you use your garage as an office or a place to escape.
    68. You'll hear the noise and interruptions from home, and your family will find it easier to drop by to check on things.
    69. If this happens, an attached garage will provide less protection from airborne pollutants.
    70. A detached garage is safer. Security is threatened.

    Frequently Asked Questions About Garage

    Attached garages benefit homeowners, including Convenient to use, especially in bad weather. Less expensive to build. Able to use electrical and heating systems that are part of the home.

    With an attached garage, your space is limited and largely dictated by the house space already in place. The detached garage allows you more freedom to build, expand and re-imagine. It allows more room for landscaping.

    In practically any case, building a garage can and will increase the resale value of your home. According to Pocket Sense, the average attached garage will cost around $27,000 to build. Most homeowners see about an 81% return on their investment or an increase in the resale value of $21,000.

    A detached garage can make your home more attractive to many buyers. Appraisers will consider this and factor your garage into your home's current market value. For the vast majority of homes, adding a detached garage will add more value to the home than what the garage costs to build.

    It is generally cheaper to build an attached garage than it is to build a detached garage. That's because an attached garage utilises the existing structure of your home and only requires you to build three walls.

    Scroll to Top